Editing Horned Cannon Beetle

Jump to navigation Jump to search
You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 19: Line 19:
It is unclear whether the Horned Cannon Beetle is a new lithopod, or supposed to be the lithopod encountered in {{p1}}, having been misidentified in said game. Evidence supporting it being renamed includes the exact same behavior, being featured in promotional material alongside returning enemies, Olimar mentioning that it was once mistaken for an Armored Cannon Beetle (possibly referring to ''Pikmin'' where it was referred to as an Armored Cannon Beetle) and being a migrant lithopod just like the [[Armored Cannon Beetle]] is stated to be in the first game. It also shares its Japanese name with the Armored Cannon Beetle, and Olimar's notes in the Japanese version of ''Pikmin 4'' appear to incorporate the Armored Cannon Beetle's notes from ''Pikmin''<nowiki>'</nowiki>s enemy reel. The only evidence for it being a new creature includes differences in design beyond graphical improvements, and the unclear nature of Olimar's statement.
It is unclear whether the Horned Cannon Beetle is a new lithopod, or supposed to be the lithopod encountered in {{p1}}, having been misidentified in said game. Evidence supporting it being renamed includes the exact same behavior, being featured in promotional material alongside returning enemies, Olimar mentioning that it was once mistaken for an Armored Cannon Beetle (possibly referring to ''Pikmin'' where it was referred to as an Armored Cannon Beetle) and being a migrant lithopod just like the [[Armored Cannon Beetle]] is stated to be in the first game. It also shares its Japanese name with the Armored Cannon Beetle, and Olimar's notes in the Japanese version of ''Pikmin 4'' appear to incorporate the Armored Cannon Beetle's notes from ''Pikmin''<nowiki>'</nowiki>s enemy reel. The only evidence for it being a new creature includes differences in design beyond graphical improvements, and the unclear nature of Olimar's statement.


Judging by the Japanese version, it seems that the Armored Cannon Beetle in ''Pikmin'' is indeed the same as the Horned Cannon Beetle in ''Pikmin 4''. The new name seems to be an attempt to better distinguish it from the Armored Cannon Larva, as the larva was never meant to belong to the same species as the ''Pikmin'' enemy, with the Armored Cannon Beetle's name being repurposed as referring to the Armored Cannon Larva's species outside of its larval stage. It is unknown why the species introduced first was renamed, especially considering the lithopod is said to have a stronger carapace than its relatives.
Judging by the Japanese version, it seems that the lithopod in ''Pikmin'' is indeed the same lithopod in ''Pikmin 4''. The new name seems to be an attempt to fix a translation error, in that the Armored Cannon Larva was never meant to be related to the ''Pikmin'' boss. In fact, in Japan the larva is of the continental species, known as the Strong-Armed Cannon Beetle in the Player's Guide. It is unknown why the species introduced first was renamed, and it's especially ironic considering the lithopod is said to have a stronger carapace than the Strong Armed Cannon Beetle, now known as the Armored Cannon Beetle. The translation error may stem from the use of technical names in the Player's Guide leading to the ''Pikmin 2'' localization staff believing Strong-Armed to be the technical name of the Armored. A similar error can be found in the Prima Guide, which changes the mention of the Strong-Armed to the Armored, so it is likely these mistakes are related.  ''Pikmin 4'''s disregard for the Player's Guide complicates the situation.


== Stats ==
== Stats ==

Please note that all contributions to Pikipedia are considered to be released under the Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported license (see Pikipedia:Copyrights for details). Your changes will be visible immediately. Please enter a summary of your changes above.

Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)