Editing Talk:Obstacle
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision | Your text | ||
Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
== Articles for Heavy Obstacle and High Ledge? == | == Articles for Heavy Obstacle and High Ledge? == | ||
This article's big list has links to specific pages about all of the obstacles, with the exception of 3 items in the list: 'Buried treasure, fruit, or Sparklium Seeds', 'High ledges', and 'Purple Pikmin needed'. While the first one's link to the [[Dig]] article works, the other 2 deserve articles in my opinion. An article for '''[[Heavy obstacle]]''' could talk about the required use of Purple Pikmin to push down the paper bag in the Awakening Wood, as well as collecting the Spherical Atlas, Geographic Projection, and Doomsday Apparatus (as they are obstacles to completing the game). While the Purple Pikmin article already has a list of [[Purple Pikmin#Mandatory uses|mandatory uses]], these uses are tied to the obstacle of heavy weights, just as the mandatory uses of Yellow Pikmin are tied to electricity or high ledges, and the mandatory uses of Blue Pikmin are tied to water. An article for '''[[High ledge]]''' would be even more useful, as several ship parts, treasures, and fruits are made harder to access by being too high for most types to reach, and this is an obstacle with enough information to describe it, especially considering the various exploits to bypass the height barrier. Do these topics deserve their own articles, or is their current coverage good enough? - [[User: | This article's big list has links to specific pages about all of the obstacles, with the exception of 3 items in the list: 'Buried treasure, fruit, or Sparklium Seeds', 'High ledges', and 'Purple Pikmin needed'. While the first one's link to the [[Dig]] article works, the other 2 deserve articles in my opinion. An article for '''[[Heavy obstacle]]''' could talk about the required use of Purple Pikmin to push down the paper bag in the Awakening Wood, as well as collecting the Spherical Atlas, Geographic Projection, and Doomsday Apparatus (as they are obstacles to completing the game). While the Purple Pikmin article already has a list of [[Purple Pikmin#Mandatory uses|mandatory uses]], these uses are tied to the obstacle of heavy weights, just as the mandatory uses of Yellow Pikmin are tied to electricity or high ledges, and the mandatory uses of Blue Pikmin are tied to water. An article for '''[[High ledge]]''' would be even more useful, as several ship parts, treasures, and fruits are made harder to access by being too high for most types to reach, and this is an obstacle with enough information to describe it, especially considering the various exploits to bypass the height barrier. Do these topics deserve their own articles, or is their current coverage good enough? - [[User:Botanist|Botanist]] ([[User talk:Botanist|talk]]) 18:49, July 12, 2020 (EDT) | ||
:I'm starting to debate if they should even count in the first place. An obstacle should be something that is in the way of your goal, so I guess something being too heavy to carry normally, or too high to reach can count as an obstacle. But if we define obstacles as actual objects, then the notions of weight and height don't really count. I think it's fine to keep them, but there is merit in getting rid of them too. Anyway, I think simply linking to the Purple Pikmin and Yellow Pikmin articles for those two "obstacles" is enough... There is nothing that can be said about heavy obstacles that isn't explained in the Purple Pikmin article, and if the reader wants a list of such obstacles, they have the recommended and mandatory uses listed in that same article. Same goes for high ledges and Yellow Pikmin. — '''{''[[User:Espyo|Espyo]]''<sup>[[User talk:Espyo|T]]</sup>}''' 07:18, July 16, 2020 (EDT) | :I'm starting to debate if they should even count in the first place. An obstacle should be something that is in the way of your goal, so I guess something being too heavy to carry normally, or too high to reach can count as an obstacle. But if we define obstacles as actual objects, then the notions of weight and height don't really count. I think it's fine to keep them, but there is merit in getting rid of them too. Anyway, I think simply linking to the Purple Pikmin and Yellow Pikmin articles for those two "obstacles" is enough... There is nothing that can be said about heavy obstacles that isn't explained in the Purple Pikmin article, and if the reader wants a list of such obstacles, they have the recommended and mandatory uses listed in that same article. Same goes for high ledges and Yellow Pikmin. — '''{''[[User:Espyo|Espyo]]''<sup>[[User talk:Espyo|T]]</sup>}''' 07:18, July 16, 2020 (EDT) | ||
Line 79: | Line 79: | ||
* Tool: Anything whose existence can be used by the player to help in their pursuit of a goal. | * Tool: Anything whose existence can be used by the player to help in their pursuit of a goal. | ||
We might be able to lump everything into these two categories. I don't think there's anything that's ambiguous. Even objects that kinda apply to both will have one they apply much more to (e.g. cardboard boxes can be climbed on top of, but they're mainly in the way). From these two categories, we can sub-divide further. Or just stay with this two-way categorization. Also yeah, minor obstacles would be included in the list like any other entry, but since there isn't much to say about them, their info should still just be confined to a section. — '''{''[[User:Espyo|Espyo]]''<sup>[[User talk:Espyo|T]]</sup>}''' 15:10, October 25, 2021 (EDT) | We might be able to lump everything into these two categories. I don't think there's anything that's ambiguous. Even objects that kinda apply to both will have one they apply much more to (e.g. cardboard boxes can be climbed on top of, but they're mainly in the way). From these two categories, we can sub-divide further. Or just stay with this two-way categorization. Also yeah, minor obstacles would be included in the list like any other entry, but since there isn't much to say about them, their info should still just be confined to a section. — '''{''[[User:Espyo|Espyo]]''<sup>[[User talk:Espyo|T]]</sup>}''' 15:10, October 25, 2021 (EDT) | ||
:Alright, now that ''Pikmin Bloom'' has been out for a few months, it's time to return to this discussion. I think that simpler classification is great – it's effectively going back to the "Obstacles"/"Interactive objects" distinction that this discussion started with, but with better terminology. And it also provides a way to classify objects that are not interactive yet are also not a part of the basic scenery. Let's see how this categorization attempt goes: | :Alright, now that ''Pikmin Bloom'' has been out for a few months, it's time to return to this discussion. I think that simpler classification is great – it's effectively going back to the "Obstacles"/"Interactive objects" distinction that this discussion started with, but with better terminology. And it also provides a way to classify objects that are not interactive yet are also not a part of the basic scenery. Let's see how this categorization attempt goes: | ||
:*'''Obstacles''': [[Arachnode web]], [[bamboo gate]], [[boulder]], [[bramble gate]], [[brick wall]], [[Burgeoning Spiderwort mold]], buried items, [[cardboard box]], [[clipboard]], [[clog]], [[cobblestone block]], [[crystal nodule]], [[crystal wall]], [[dam]], [[dirt block]], [[dirt wall]], [[electric gate]], [[electrical wire]], [[fire geyser]], [[flames]], [[gas pipe]], high ledges, [[hydroe bramble]], [[icicle crystal]], [[iron block]], [[Kingcap]], [[large crystal]], [[paper bag]], heavy item, [[reinforced wall]], [[small crystal]], [[Spotcap]], [[tin box]], [[trowel]], [[tunnel]], [[water]] body, [[wooden stake]] | :*'''Obstacles''': [[Arachnode web]], [[bamboo gate]], [[boulder]], [[bramble gate]], [[brick wall]], [[Burgeoning Spiderwort mold]], buried items, [[cardboard box]], [[clipboard]], [[clog]], [[cobblestone block]], [[crystal nodule]], [[crystal wall]], [[dam]], [[dirt block]], [[dirt wall]], [[electric gate]], [[electrical wire]], [[fire geyser]], [[flames]], [[gas pipe]], high ledges, [[hydroe bramble]], [[icicle crystal]], [[iron block]], [[Kingcap]], [[large crystal]], [[paper bag]], heavy item, [[reinforced wall]], [[small crystal]], [[Spotcap]], [[tin box]], [[trowel]], [[tunnel]], [[water]] body, [[wooden stake]] | ||
Line 86: | Line 85: | ||
:*'''Minor tools''': floating bottle, leaf platform, metal pipe, rusted rod, water sac | :*'''Minor tools''': floating bottle, leaf platform, metal pipe, rusted rod, water sac | ||
:That only leaves one unclear case: is a [[bridge]] an obstacle or a tool? I think this system works great otherwise. — [[User:Soprano|'''Soprano''']]<sub>[[User talk:Soprano|''(talk)'']]</sub> 00:05, March 10, 2022 (EST) | :That only leaves one unclear case: is a [[bridge]] an obstacle or a tool? I think this system works great otherwise. — [[User:Soprano|'''Soprano''']]<sub>[[User talk:Soprano|''(talk)'']]</sub> 00:05, March 10, 2022 (EST) | ||
::Great! Yeah, a bridge is kinda both, huh... But I guess if we think about it practically, the ''water body'' is the obstacle, the ''bridge'' is a tool used to surpass that obstacle. I vote for bridges being tools. This logic can also probably be applied to other cases, like water sac vs fire, high ledge vs Bouncy Mushroom, etc. That said, we might be able to further sub-divide, or at least sub-divide the obstacle list. Maybe between man-made and natural? Or between harmful and simply "in the way"? — '''{''[[User:Espyo|Espyo]]''<sup>[[User talk:Espyo|T]]</sup>}''' 17:07, March 19, 2022 (EDT) | ::Great! Yeah, a bridge is kinda both, huh... But I guess if we think about it practically, the ''water body'' is the obstacle, the ''bridge'' is a tool used to surpass that obstacle. I vote for bridges being tools. This logic can also probably be applied to other cases, like water sac vs fire, high ledge vs Bouncy Mushroom, etc. That said, we might be able to further sub-divide, or at least sub-divide the obstacle list. Maybe between man-made and natural? Or between harmful and simply "in the way"? — '''{''[[User:Espyo|Espyo]]''<sup>[[User talk:Espyo|T]]</sup>}''' 17:07, March 19, 2022 (EDT) | ||
:::Well, more important than the subdivision of the list is the process by which this article will be split. There are a lot of pages that link to the Obstacle article, mostly due to the row in [[Template:Infobox area]], and also all the images and templates for the different types of obstacles/tools. Splitting the article in two would require updating the area infobox template and all the pages that use it, which would be a lot of work. We'd also have to consider what to do about [[Template:Obstacles]] (perhaps it could be used for both), and there are likely other things that would have to be changed. So there's a lot to do; how should we go about this? — [[User:Soprano|'''Soprano''']]<sub>[[User talk:Soprano|''(talk)'']]</sub> 19:19, March 19, 2022 (EDT) | :::Well, more important than the subdivision of the list is the process by which this article will be split. There are a lot of pages that link to the Obstacle article, mostly due to the row in [[Template:Infobox area]], and also all the images and templates for the different types of obstacles/tools. Splitting the article in two would require updating the area infobox template and all the pages that use it, which would be a lot of work. We'd also have to consider what to do about [[Template:Obstacles]] (perhaps it could be used for both), and there are likely other things that would have to be changed. So there's a lot to do; how should we go about this? — [[User:Soprano|'''Soprano''']]<sub>[[User talk:Soprano|''(talk)'']]</sub> 19:19, March 19, 2022 (EDT) | ||
::::I'd honestly recommend we start from a clean slate on this. As more Pikmin games get released, we can't keep accumulating technical debt by lumping everything as an "obstacle". We should start splitting now, which means fixing everything, including all of those links. I actually don't think there are that many. — '''{''[[User:Espyo|Espyo]]''<sup>[[User talk:Espyo|T]]</sup>}''' 11:06, March 20, 2022 (EDT) | ::::I'd honestly recommend we start from a clean slate on this. As more Pikmin games get released, we can't keep accumulating technical debt by lumping everything as an "obstacle". We should start splitting now, which means fixing everything, including all of those links. I actually don't think there are that many. — '''{''[[User:Espyo|Espyo]]''<sup>[[User talk:Espyo|T]]</sup>}''' 11:06, March 20, 2022 (EDT) | ||
:::::Alright, so what's the process for doing this? | :::::Alright, so what's the process for doing this? | ||
:::::# Create a new [[Tool]] article, very similar to the Obstacle article, but with only the tools in the table. | :::::# Create a new [[Tool]] article, very similar to the Obstacle article, but with only the tools in the table. | ||
Line 102: | Line 97: | ||
:::::# Later, go though the images and templates for obstacle icons and recategorize them. | :::::# Later, go though the images and templates for obstacle icons and recategorize them. | ||
:::::That should be doable over a few days, right? I'm fine with doing most of it (though it would be good if you could help with the area articles). — [[User:Soprano|'''Soprano''']]<sub>[[User talk:Soprano|''(talk)'']]</sub> 17:17, March 20, 2022 (EDT) | :::::That should be doable over a few days, right? I'm fine with doing most of it (though it would be good if you could help with the area articles). — [[User:Soprano|'''Soprano''']]<sub>[[User talk:Soprano|''(talk)'']]</sub> 17:17, March 20, 2022 (EDT) | ||