This user is an inactive administrator on this wiki. Even though this user is inactive they still have the power to make special adjustments, such as protecting pages from regular user's edits to prevent abuse, and deleting bad pages. Most importantly, this user can block misbehaving editors.
Welcome to my userpage, where I explain nothing about myself, save for this introductory paragraph. At the moment I'm using this as a brain dumping site for ideas which don't fit anywhere else. I'd like to note also that I have not studied biology formally outside of high school, taking most of what I know from books, television, and Wikipedia, so keep in mind that whatever I write is not unlikely to be riddled with inconsistencies and falsehood, and criticism is welcome.
Pikmin being the product of someone's imagination, nothing can be said about them with any real degree of certainty, but much can be inferred from their behavior and what little information is slipped to us from in-game dialogue. Actually, in a way, the lack of real canonical information on creatures into which an enormous amount of thought and detail were obviously put makes studying Pikmin a bit like studying real animals in that nature has no guides or definitions, so it is entirely up to us to make sense of it.
In the absence of fossil or genetic data (I could not expect Nintendo to put that much thought into it), I've constructed a family tree of Pikmin and relatives based on observable differences and information given to us from the game.
Immediately worthy of note is the fact that I placed everything in the plant kingdom, not animal or some new kingdom, with Pikmin and relatives making up their own phylum. Though Pikmin have some animal-like features and abilities, such as free locomotion, what differentiates animals from plants is often not so much what they have, but what they don't have that plants do, such as chlorophyll photosynthesis (save like one or two species of animal plankton). Whereas evolving such things would require a great leap from animals, things like self-driven movement and sight, if even only in some bare, basic form, are already possessed by more than a handful of plants. Not only that, but certain features such as Pikmin flowers which seem to serve no purpose could be considered throwbacks from a plant origin.
As for the distinction between subterranean "Candypop-only" Pikmin and Onion-dwelling ones, much is just speculation. The absence of White and Purple Onions does not necessarily mean none exist, nor that White and Purple Pikmin are designed to be subterranean, but the fact that both have pink flowers seems to suggest a common ancestor which diverged from the rest of the group some time ago. Despite that, they still share many similarities, and it may turn out with further evidence that they are no less close in relation to Reds, Yellows, and Blues than those Pikmin are to each other.
With the generic separation of the other Pikmin in mind, I felt the need to further separate Bulbmin from the rest of the group, so I created a subfamily for them.
Food and energy
Just like animals, plants need food and oxygen to make energy. Unlike (most) animals, plants are able to make their own food through photosynthesis by using energy from the sun to combine carbon-dioxide and water into sugars, but they still need oxygen in order to get energy their cells can use from those sugars and other nutrients. It's easy to imagine that if a plant had some other way of obtaining nutrients, it might not even need to photosynthesize (though if it didn't it would arguably no longer be considered a plant).
I'm sure Pikmin photosynthesize to some degree, which is probably how they're able to grow flowers when left in the ground, but when they're out working, running, and fighting, I highly doubt that the single tiny leaf atop a Pikmin's head is able to collect near enough energy to support such an active lifestyle. Since Pikmin are never observed to eat anything besides the occasional drop of nectar, I would have to guess that the Onion supplies Pikmin with nutrients from food they have brought it, which it breaks down for them so all that complicated digestive machinery doesn't take up precious space in their tiny, agile bodies. Pikmin probably store the energy in their bodies somehow, like how animals use fat tissue, and are "recharged" by the Onion at the end of the day.
Onions and Candypops, too, probably don't photosynthesize much, if at all, given they have no leaves (or very small leaves in the case of Candypops, which live mostly underground and probably couldn't get enough sunlight to survive even if they wanted to). Chrysanthemums are in the same boat as everything else, but are probably able to do all the hunting, eating, and digesting themselves. As for Pellet Posies...I can only imagine. Their ability to grow so quickly and produce such nutritious pellets without large leaves or some other visible means of obtaining food baffles me. Maybe they extract nutrients from decaying remains of animals underground with the aid of symbiotic fungus. Who knows?
Pikmin are obviously social creatures, similar to bees, ants, and termites, but evolved independently of them. They share much in common, but there's also a lot that's different. Whereas social insects communicate mostly by smell, Pikmin seem to do it by sight and sound; I can't say for sure whether or not Pikmin smell at all, but the fact that they follow Olimar, who could not possibly produce Pikmin pheromones, means its part in their communication must be minimal at best.
The auditory part is pretty easy to see. Pikmin sing all the time, but more than just being cute, I think their songs are vital to keeping themselves together and organized. It also explains why they react so strongly to Olimar's whistle and whatever that little horn thing he does is when the C-stick is used.
The visual part requires a bit more imagination. It's pretty clear that Pikmin can see - they have eyes after all - but it plays a more important and complicated role than just "see food, attack food." Since they don't likely smell very much, I think Pikmin use their sight to identify other members of their species, but their visual acuity and processing power are likely limited by their size, so they need a fast and simple way of doing so, something that is unique to them; I believe the leaves serve this purpose. Evidence for this idea is the fact that Pikmin leaves glow when they are idle, a clear visual signal of something (possibly to call the attention of the pack should a Pikmin become lost or stranded). The color of a Pikmin's body also always contrasts that of its leaf, so it is easily recognizable (White Pikmin have pink flowers, not white, so there is still contrast. It is also because of this that I firmly believe there should never and will never be Green Pikmin, since its body would blend with its leaf, which must be green). If one accepts this idea, it's easy to imagine why a Pikmin might follow Olimar, whose shining antenna probably sparks the same visual cues they get from other Pikmin, but to a much larger degree. It also explains why Pikmin accept juvenile Bulbmin, which probably smell and look just like Bulborbs save for their recognizable leaves, as their own (the adults are just so absurdly huge that they probably don't register as anything but an enemy to Pikmin).
What I want from Pikmin 3
Pikmin 2 was a vast improvement on the first game, fixing little glitches, annoyances, and being overall more streamlined, but while neither game was bad, there are still certain areas of the gameplay that I think could be improved upon.
Dynamics between Pikmin colors
New Pikmin colors are pretty much a given, and I wouldn't have it any other way, but I'm concerned that having too many colors available at once brings issues with balance and makes creating a well-rounded group very difficult. For instance, Purple Pikmin in Pikmin 2 greatly overshadowed Red Pikmin in their combat ability, making Reds all but useless* while Purples were pretty much essential, but their speed meant the entire group was forced to move at their pace, causing frustration. Yellow Pikmin, too, have struggled to be useful in both games, and were usually only taken along in very specific situations where there is an electrical hazard or a wall that needs to be bombed.
My proposed solution would be to separate the different colors and only allow those that work well together to be played together. The way I'd probably do this is to divide the main game into several sub-games, similar to Kirby Superstar (which I admittedly have never played), and have certain colors exclusive to one or two sub-games.
*Fire resistance does not do them a whole lot of good. Fire traps are arguably the least deadly, since they can be destroyed by any color, unlike poison traps, and don't kill Pikmin instantly, unlike electric traps.
I did not really like caves in Pikmin 2. While I can understand why the 30-day limit was taken away in Pikmin 2, the time limit on daylight still forced players to plan, multitask, and take risks, all of which I think are good things. Caves, on the other hand, gave players as much time as they wanted, allowing them to play it safe by not even using Pikmin and just punching enemies to death with their captains. It ended up being a very boring and tedious experience, which I felt obliged to do because I didn't want to lose any Pikmin in a place where I couldn't grow more.
I will acknowledge that caves offered something unique, but the change of pace from above-ground play was too much. If caves are to be used, I'd like to see their use limited, perhaps to a sub-game as mentioned above.
The addition of multiplayer to Pikmin 2 was pretty awesome, but limited. I'd have liked for the main game to be playable with a friend, although I realize it wasn't really designed for that, so perhaps Pikmin 3 can be designed with that in mind. I'd also like online capability, and disagree with that idea that online is only for competitive play, as I have a few close friends with whom I'd love to be able to play Pikmin cooperatively. That is of course not to say that online multiplayer would be limited to co-op -- vs. is fun too.
See User:Jimbo Jambo/notes for ship part notes.