Forum:We aren't a strategy guide.: Difference between revisions

From Pikipedia, the Pikmin wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 23: Line 23:


By writing that, you're bringing it up yourself; if you start telling people not to do something before they've done it, it'll be taken negatively by some.  If you start without the assumption people are going to base their vote on anything other than the topic, they won't even think of it.{{User:Greenpickle/sig}}
By writing that, you're bringing it up yourself; if you start telling people not to do something before they've done it, it'll be taken negatively by some.  If you start without the assumption people are going to base their vote on anything other than the topic, they won't even think of it.{{User:Greenpickle/sig}}
:I don't see how looking at Wikipedia has anything to do with image placement. I'm saying that the images shouldn't be in sections where they aren't needed, and if you want to keep the sections that make the article look like a page in a guide, we should place the images in a gallery. I'm capable of this, as it really isn't that hard. <font face="Eurostile" size="3">[[User:Blue Ninjakoopa|<span style="color:#00008B">BNK</span>]]</font><sup> <nowiki>[</nowiki>[[Special:EditCount/Blue Ninjakoopa|E]]|[[User talk:Blue Ninjakoopa|T]]|[[Special:Contributions/Blue Ninjakoopa|C]]]</sup> 12:26, May 27, 2010 (UTC)
:I don't see how looking at Wikipedia has anything to do with image placement. I'm saying that the images shouldn't be in sections where they aren't needed, and if you want to keep the sections that make the article look like a page in a guide, we should place the images in a gallery. I'm capable of this, as it really isn't that hard. <font face="Eurostile" size="3">[[User:Blue Ninjakoopa|<span style="color:#00008B">BNK</span>]]</font><sup> <nowiki>[</nowiki>[[Special:EditCount/Blue Ninjakoopa|E]]|[[User talk:Blue Ninjakoopa|T]]|[[Special:Contributions/Blue Ninjakoopa|C]]]</sup> 12:26, May 27, 2010 (UTC)


:I thought I was doing the opposite, but okay.  And right, so you're talking about ''general'' pictures that aren't relevant to any particular section?  You weren't clear before.  Then sure, but I think if there are long stretches of the page without any images, it makes sense to try to find one that fits in with whatever the text there is about and keep it up out of the gallery.{{User:Greenpickle/sig}}
::I thought I was doing the opposite, but okay.  And right, so you're talking about ''general'' pictures that aren't relevant to any particular section?  You weren't clear before.  Then sure, but I think if there are long stretches of the page without any images, it makes sense to try to find one that fits in with whatever the text there is about and keep it up out of the gallery.
 
::Also, while I'm here: you might want to look at [[Forum:Strategy sections|this]], since you're the one who changed them all, and if you have strong feelings about it I don't want you to miss the discussion.
 
::Oh, and do you think you could double-space your comments from other ones to unclutter the edit window a bit?{{User:Greenpickle/sig}}

Revision as of 09:32, May 27, 2010

Forums: Index > Watercooler (Pikipedia) > We aren't a strategy guide.


This has been bugging me ever since I first visited this wikia. On all of the enemy articles, there is a section entitled "How to kill/Killing strategy" that instructs the reader on how to kill the enemy. We aren't a strategy guide, and that section should be removed or, in the first paragraph of the article it can state the creature's weakness, etc. This is an encyclopedia, not a Nintendo Power strategy guide. I propose we remove that unnecessary section and replace it with one describing its appearance. The images scattered all over the article will also be moved to a gallery so, in general, the article looks better and less messy.

Notice: I advise you all to be reasonable with your vote and to leave your personal qualms with me in the past. Your emotions really shouldn't be your deciding factor. Thanks, BNK [E|T|C] 23:22, May 23, 2010 (UTC)

Support

Oppose

We are supposed to be a library of all things Pikmin, and Pikmin is not a very large series, so I don't see how having strategy hurts us in any way. While we are part of Wikia, we also have a large degree of independence, and we're not always obliged to do something just because everyone else does. —Jimbo Jambo 04:57, May 24, 2010 (UTC)

I find this is pretty much the most important part of each page. Both beginners as well as more experienced players can get information on how to defeat enemies with an effective strategy, which, if I'm not mistaken, is the game's main objective. I'm willing to break some standards to keep this.--Prezintenden

  • GP - as above.

Comment

The images scattered all over the article will also be moved to a gallery so, in general, the article looks better and less messy.

Look at Wikipedia.

I advise you all to be reasonable with your vote and to leave your personal qualms with me in the past. Your emotions really shouldn't be your deciding factor.

By writing that, you're bringing it up yourself; if you start telling people not to do something before they've done it, it'll be taken negatively by some. If you start without the assumption people are going to base their vote on anything other than the topic, they won't even think of it. GP

I don't see how looking at Wikipedia has anything to do with image placement. I'm saying that the images shouldn't be in sections where they aren't needed, and if you want to keep the sections that make the article look like a page in a guide, we should place the images in a gallery. I'm capable of this, as it really isn't that hard. BNK [E|T|C] 12:26, May 27, 2010 (UTC)
I thought I was doing the opposite, but okay. And right, so you're talking about general pictures that aren't relevant to any particular section? You weren't clear before. Then sure, but I think if there are long stretches of the page without any images, it makes sense to try to find one that fits in with whatever the text there is about and keep it up out of the gallery.
Also, while I'm here: you might want to look at this, since you're the one who changed them all, and if you have strong feelings about it I don't want you to miss the discussion.
Oh, and do you think you could double-space your comments from other ones to unclutter the edit window a bit? GP