Talk:Cave

I'm not sure of that. I know that I was able to leave my Pikmin out and go in a cave when I did my no-death run, but that was always right after they brought a treasure to the base. Does anyone know for sure? I can't test it at the moment.--Prezintenden

I just tried it, actually. Any Pikmin left idle when you enter a cave, no matter how far from the landing site they are, will return to their Onion safely. —Jimbo Jambo

---

Hang on, what? I thought the only place violet candypops disappeared was Emergence Cave. There are plenty of caves with violet candypops in them, and I visited those with a ship full of purples. —Jimbo Jambo

Then change it... ~CrystalLucario~ 11:20, 7 July 2008 (UTC)

I did, it was just re-added by Greenpickle. Pay attention, foo'. —Jimbo Jambo

I was going by what Miles claimed. I'll have to ask him. GP

[17:09] <Miles> 2 in Emergence Cave 2
[17:09] <Miles> 2 in Hole of Beasts 2
[17:09] <Miles> 1 in Frontier Cavern 1
[17:09] <Miles> 1 in Citadel of Spiders 2
[17:09] <Miles> 1 in Shower Room 2
[17:10] <Greenpickle> ?
[17:10] <Greenpickle> Those are ones that disappear?
[17:10] <Greenpickle> Wait, what?
[17:10] <Greenpickle> '1 in Citadel of Spiders 2 '
[17:10] <Greenpickle> ?
[17:11] <Miles> Unless I'm not remembering correctly, yes... >_>
[17:12] <Greenpickle> But...
[17:13] <Greenpickle> Why two numbers for each?
[17:13] <Greenpickle> oh, sublevel?
[17:13] <Miles> 1 candypop on Citadel of Spiders sublevel 2
[17:13] <Greenpickle> And the limit for all is 20, right?
[17:13] <Miles> Yes.
[17:14] <Miles> Also 20 for the WFG Ivory candypops...

Yay? GP

Okay, I've never noticed that. I think it's worth checking out.... Even still though, that's only five caves, which leaves six with candypops that don't disappear. —Jimbo Jambo

Never said there were more... GP

No, but the current text implies that a majority of violet candypops disappear. —Jimbo Jambo

And...? ~CrystalLucario~ 18:08, 7 July 2008 (UTC)

You're kidding, right?... Why is everyone trying to pull my leg today? —Jimbo Jambo

...I'm confusled... I didn't know Miles could talk... ~CrystalLucario~ 22:50, 7 July 2008 (UTC)

...Yeah, it gets you the first time. Also, JJ, 'trying'? 'Everyone'? 'Leg'? GP

Stop it! You're confusing me! I can't detect sarcasm within written text! —Jimbo Jambo

Neither can Prez. :P But seriously make it CLEAR what your telling us we DO NOT GET IT! ~CrystalLucario~ 11:44, 9 July 2008 (UTC)

This page implies something that simply isn't true. I'm amazed that you with your "OMG NO SPECUMALATION MUST BE 100% HARD FACT" attitude aren't tearing up the page by now. —Jimbo Jambo

You told me not to do that. And I'm so confused I couldn't even tell it was speculation... ~CrystalLucario~ 17:25, 9 July 2008 (UTC)

It's not speculation, but it's not fact either. In fact, it's completely wrong. I would have thought you would have something to say about that. —Jimbo Jambo

...What is? GP

...This entire conversation is about one single phrase which I pointed out in the first post up there. —Jimbo Jambo

So why is there the big Miles thing up there? Pointless. And I really only hate speculation, but non-factualness is annoying too... ~CrystalLucario~ 22:26, 9 July 2008 (UTC)

Er, the Miles thing is to show he said JJ was wrong, which I thought would end the argument. You don't believe Miles? GP

I was wrong in thinking that Emergence Cave was the only place they disappeared in, but I'm still right in that the number of caves they do disappear in is a minority, which you all, far from disagreeing with, actually admitted. I'm kind of confused as to what everyone's reservations about editing the text are. —Jimbo Jambo

Firstly, I wouldn't consider 5 in 14 a minority. Secondly, it already says that only 'some' diappear; how would you change it? GP

Five is less than half of 14, which I'm sure you already know, making it a minority as opposed to a majority. Rather than listing caves in which candypops do not disappear, I think it should list caves in which they do disappear. If caves in which candypops disappear are the subject, then such caves should be used as the example. —Jimbo Jambo

Why not just make the changes? I'm still not sure why it matters, but...just... GP

I changed ShadowRaptor's revision, and you undid mine and rewrote it. I'm just making sure everything's fine with this.... —Jimbo Jambo

My head... ~CrystalLucario~ 22:43, 10 July 2008 (UTC)