Talk:Strawberry Flower: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (5 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Do we need this? == | |||
I agree with the non-redirecting, but should we have a page for the band itself? There's not that much worth knowing, and it all could be put on Ai no Uta.--{{User:Prezintenden/sig}} | I agree with the non-redirecting, but should we have a page for the band itself? There's not that much worth knowing, and it all could be put on Ai no Uta.--{{User:Prezintenden/sig}} | ||
:Errrr... It should get its own page but it needs a lot of fixing up... >.>... yeh... '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[ | :Errrr... It should get its own page but it needs a lot of fixing up... >.>... yeh... '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[File:Redpikminsprite.jpg]]<b>[[User talk:Crystal_lucario|<span style="color:Black">Lucario~</span>]]</b> '''And I approve this message.''' | ||
... this is a terrible article.. | ... this is a terrible article.. | ||
:NO RLY?!?! That is why I redirected it... I'll fix'er up '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[ | :NO RLY?!?! That is why I redirected it... I'll fix'er up '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[File:Redpikminsprite.jpg]]<b>[[User talk:Crystal_lucario|<span style="color:Black">Lucario~</span>]]</b> '''And I approve this message.''' | ||
It's a dump, probably from Wikipedia, so none of the templates or links will work. I assume you've fixed that though. I haven't looked at it yet. {{user:Jimbo Jambo/sig}} | It's a dump, probably from Wikipedia, so none of the templates or links will work. I assume you've fixed that though. I haven't looked at it yet. {{user:Jimbo Jambo/sig}} | ||
| Line 11: | Line 12: | ||
Come to think of it, I've seen something awfully familiar to this on Wikipedia... [[User:Portal-Kombat|<span style="color:blue">Portal-</span>]][[User_talk:Portal-Kombat|<span style="color:orange">Kombat</span>]] | Come to think of it, I've seen something awfully familiar to this on Wikipedia... [[User:Portal-Kombat|<span style="color:blue">Portal-</span>]][[User_talk:Portal-Kombat|<span style="color:orange">Kombat</span>]] | ||
:Not fixed '>.> '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[ | :Not fixed '>.> '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[File:Redpikminsprite.jpg]]<b>[[User talk:Crystal_lucario|<span style="color:Black">Lucario~</span>]]</b> '''And I approve this message.''' | ||
If a band which which is only indirectly related to Pikmin gets an article, should we also make articles for things like Nintendo, the Nintendo Gamecube, and so on? {{user:Jimbo Jambo/sig}} | If a band which which is only indirectly related to Pikmin gets an article, should we also make articles for things like Nintendo, the Nintendo Gamecube, and so on? {{user:Jimbo Jambo/sig}} | ||
:I wanted a redirect... '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[ | :I wanted a redirect... '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[File:Redpikminsprite.jpg]]<b>[[User talk:Crystal_lucario|<span style="color:Black">Lucario~</span>]]</b> '''And I approve this message.''' | ||
::Yeah, and I think I might agree with you. I'm actually not totally sure though. Those articles would be the ideal place for the "Real-world subject" template. {{user:Jimbo Jambo/sig}} | ::Yeah, and I think I might agree with you. I'm actually not totally sure though. Those articles would be the ideal place for the "Real-world subject" template. {{user:Jimbo Jambo/sig}} | ||
| Line 21: | Line 22: | ||
:So... we need to fix up this artical, make [[Gamecube]], [[Nintendo]], errrr.... any others... | :So... we need to fix up this artical, make [[Gamecube]], [[Nintendo]], errrr.... any others... | ||
:Did anyone else notice Green has been gone?... '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[ | :Did anyone else notice Green has been gone?... '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[File:Redpikminsprite.jpg]]<b>[[User talk:Crystal_lucario|<span style="color:Black">Lucario~</span>]]</b> '''And I approve this message.''' | ||
Also, there's this: http://vgmdb.net/artist/2982 [[User:IAMAHIPO ocolor|<span style="color:Black">IAMAHIP<b>O_o</b></span><span style="color:Red">c</span><span style="color:#ddbb00">o</span><span style="color:Blue">l</span><span style="color:Purple">o</span><span style="color:Grey">r</span>]] 15:58, 31 October 2008 (UTC) | Also, there's this: http://vgmdb.net/artist/2982 [[User:IAMAHIPO ocolor|<span style="color:Black">IAMAHIP<b>O_o</b></span><span style="color:Red">c</span><span style="color:#ddbb00">o</span><span style="color:Blue">l</span><span style="color:Purple">o</span><span style="color:Grey">r</span>]] 15:58, 31 October 2008 (UTC) | ||
:Wow... that had so much info... '''I'm''' [[User:Crystal_lucario|<b><span style="color:Blue">~Crystal</span></b>]][[File:Redpikminsprite.jpg]]<b>[[User talk:Crystal_lucario|<span style="color:Black">Lucario~</span>]]</b> '''And I approve this message.''' | |||
== Comment by Team-kuppa on 19th June 2014 == | |||
one word CUTE! - [[User:Team-kuppa|Team-kuppa]] ([[User talk:Team-kuppa|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Team-kuppa|contribs]]) | |||
== This article's factual accuracy == | |||
Until recently, this article and Wikipedia's article on Strawberry Flower have been filled with factual inaccuracies, and this has led to a lot of misconceptions about what Strawberry Flower actually were. The main piece of false information that has spread around is that Strawberry Flower was a {{w|virtual band}} with members who were Pikmin. This was probably made up by the creator of the Wikipedia article, and amazingly that claim has expanded over the years with people adding more members to the band as more Pikmin types have been introduced, with no citation of original sources. The truth is that Strawberry Flower was a duo, with known members that have documented musical careers. The [[Song of Hey! Pikmin|Song of ''Hey! Pikmin'']] also has no connection to the band. A year and a half ago, an editor rewrote Wikipedia's article to be factually accurate, citing sources from the time. That editor copied those changes to Pikipedia, but they were reverted because the text was copied without attribution. (As it turns out though, the very first version of our article was a direct copy from Wikipedia's article at the time.) After looking at some of those sources, I have now changed our article to be accurate as well, incorporating text from Wikipedia but providing proper attribution. Hopefully this will clear up some of the misconceptions about Strawberry Flower. — [[User:Soprano|'''Soprano''']]<sub>[[User talk:Soprano|''(talk)'']]</sub> 04:13, May 5, 2023 (EDT) | |||
:: I'll clean up this page and insert citations if it makes everyone happy. Until I can scout for more citations on their single's sales, &c., all of the citations I will give to this page will have to do. {{User:White_Eye_Pikmin/sig}} 4:25 PM, 27 December, 2023 (CST) | |||
Latest revision as of 18:24, December 27, 2023
Do we need this?[edit]
I agree with the non-redirecting, but should we have a page for the band itself? There's not that much worth knowing, and it all could be put on Ai no Uta.--Prezintenden
- Errrr... It should get its own page but it needs a lot of fixing up... >.>... yeh... I'm ~Crystal
Lucario~ And I approve this message.
... this is a terrible article..
- NO RLY?!?! That is why I redirected it... I'll fix'er up I'm ~CrystalLucario~ And I approve this message.
It's a dump, probably from Wikipedia, so none of the templates or links will work. I assume you've fixed that though. I haven't looked at it yet. —Jimbo Jambo
Come to think of it, I've seen something awfully familiar to this on Wikipedia... Portal-Kombat
If a band which which is only indirectly related to Pikmin gets an article, should we also make articles for things like Nintendo, the Nintendo Gamecube, and so on? —Jimbo Jambo
Also, there's this: http://vgmdb.net/artist/2982 IAMAHIPO_ocolor 15:58, 31 October 2008 (UTC)
Comment by Team-kuppa on 19th June 2014[edit]
one word CUTE! - Team-kuppa (talk • contribs)
This article's factual accuracy[edit]
Until recently, this article and Wikipedia's article on Strawberry Flower have been filled with factual inaccuracies, and this has led to a lot of misconceptions about what Strawberry Flower actually were. The main piece of false information that has spread around is that Strawberry Flower was a virtual band with members who were Pikmin. This was probably made up by the creator of the Wikipedia article, and amazingly that claim has expanded over the years with people adding more members to the band as more Pikmin types have been introduced, with no citation of original sources. The truth is that Strawberry Flower was a duo, with known members that have documented musical careers. The Song of Hey! Pikmin also has no connection to the band. A year and a half ago, an editor rewrote Wikipedia's article to be factually accurate, citing sources from the time. That editor copied those changes to Pikipedia, but they were reverted because the text was copied without attribution. (As it turns out though, the very first version of our article was a direct copy from Wikipedia's article at the time.) After looking at some of those sources, I have now changed our article to be accurate as well, incorporating text from Wikipedia but providing proper attribution. Hopefully this will clear up some of the misconceptions about Strawberry Flower. — Soprano(talk) 04:13, May 5, 2023 (EDT)
